/r/GrilledCheese == the Greatest Sub in the Multiverse™! You will want to be careful because too much mayo will overwhelm your grilled cheese. Good memes too. [–]choppingbroccolini 1 point2 points3 points 4 years ago (0 children). Welcome to /r/GrilledCheese! Place one slice of bread in the pan, mayo-side-down. © 2020 reddit inc. All rights reserved. Some cooks we know swear by spreading mayo on the bread for grilled cheese instead of butter. [–]NotSoSlenderManPurist 0 points1 point2 points 4 years ago (0 children). I finally tried mayo yesterday since I had some homemade stuff left over. [–]jewishmedusa[S] 0 points1 point2 points 4 years ago (0 children), I have always found that mayo works better, guess I will have test out using butter again and see if my opnion changes lol, [–]jennyandthejets 0 points1 point2 points 4 years ago (0 children). Both butter and mayonnaise produce grilled-cheese sandwiches with crisp, well-browned exteriors. Mineral comparison score is based on the number of minerals by which one or the other food is richer. That's fucking disgusting. Except you, PIZZA GUY. Boom. The oils in the mayo make for the perfect crispy crust Imo, [–]Sarcasticorjustrude 17 points18 points19 points 4 years ago (0 children). I've tried grilled cheese with mayo and it just tastes funny to me. White bread, sliced cheese, and margarine are a great place to start, but eventually you may want to get fancy with cheeses like gruyère and taleggio and all manners of bread. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy. You’re welcome. Farideh shares some ideas for boosting a grilled cheese sandwich, like adding caramelized onions and quick pickled veggies. That being said, some people enjoy it, so you’re probably going to have to try for yourself. Using the same amount of mayonnaise as I did butter, I spread it evenly over one side of two slices of bread and built my grilled cheese sandwich in the same way I detail above. So let's settle this. Grilled cheese is a simple sandwich but oh so delicious. Press J to jump to the feed. Can you describe what it tastes like, is it sweeter? Infographic. Settle an argument, please! Hey, just found this sub and I'm just curious how everyone feels about using mayo instead of butter or margarine on the outside of the bread before grilling. But not enough people seem to know about it, which is why we consulted the head chef of HelloFresh, Claudia Sidoti, to get the lowdown on why mayo makes for a better substitute than butter. Melts tolerated, melts banned, melts allowed, who knows? Pictures and discussion of Cheesy Grilledness. Frankly, it's worse than throwing a couple slices of bacon into it. I don't mind dipping my sandwich in a bit of mayo though. Home to mankind's greatest invention: the grilled cheese sandwich of course! I think of it all as balance, if you are missing the zest and needs more flavor use the mayo, already has flavor and need to bring it all together use the butter. The conclusion? One is dairy, one is plant based, if that matters to you. Home to mankind's greatest invention: the grilled cheese sandwich of course! It's pretty similar to butter but maybe a little sweeter and it seems like it comes out crispier. Big fan. Mayonnaise vs Cream cheese - In-Depth Nutrition Comparison Compare. So very much not right. It's sacrilege, and you should feel bad. Sourdough just seems to work better with mayo but I would only ever use butter on white bread. /r/GrilledCheese == the Greatest Sub in the Multiverse™! U NO POST. It's a grilled cheese with a kick. Home to Man's greatest invention: the grilled cheese sandwich of course! My friend makes grilled peanut butter and jelly like this, too. "I make a lot of 'grilled' sandwiches and for years I would butter the bread with a knife before putting it in the hot pan. Which is better for you: mayonnaise or butter? Pictures and discussion of Cheesy Grilledness. Using mayo instead of butter to make grilled cheese results in a rich, golden brown exterior, and … In order to get that perfectly browned and crisp exterior in conjunction with melty, strechy cheese, you'll need to keep a close eye on the sandwich, and adjust the heat as needed, to keep all those tasty milk solids in the butter from burning. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Welcome to /r/GrilledCheese! Better than C — creamy and delicious. Dec. 8, 2016 Mayo, spread thinly, browns better than butter and is less greasy. It might seem strange to use mayo to make a grilled cheese (or even to bake chocolate cake).But it makes perfect sense when you think about the ingredients used to make mayonnaise—that creamy texture comes from whipping egg yolks and oil. Give us your brilliant photos, recipes, and grilled cheese experiences. Lots of flavor but not greasy. I bet the combination brings the best of both worlds. Domestic diva Martha Stewart recently shared her secret to what makes a grilled cheese sandwich tasty. Since it saves the step of having to soften butter to make it spreadable, we … Butter feels like the most luxurious of the options, maybe because slathering a piece of bread with butter makes it into a food that I would eat all by itself anyway. Butter, only butter. I really didn’t like it. It's no secret that mayonnaise and butter deliciously enhance the flavor of many foods. B. mayonnaise or butter? A grilled cheese with mayo will change the way you think about making this comfort food staple. BuzzFeed No wrong answers here*. Mineral Comparison. Melts tolerated, melts banned, melts allowed, who knows? If it's awesome, post it. [–]petegex 1 point2 points3 points 4 years ago (0 children). Melts tolerated, melts banned, melts allowed, who knows? However, regular mayonnaise and butter both contain saturated fat, the type of fat derived from animal sources. Tried for the first time recently, never going back to butter . Nothing beats butter when grilling. Yup, mayo, not butter, is the way to go! RELATED: 13 Grown-Ass Grilled Cheese Recipes In fact, you may want to ditch the butter entirely. it is National Grilled Cheese Day so there is a lot of grilled cheese chatter on the Internet. While the flavour is good, it doesn't give the texture that a true grilled cheese needs. Why would mayo even be a consideration? This made me really curious and I decided to try it. i do butter on both sides, wait till almost fully done, then mayo & grill both sides for a couple of seconds. A grilled cheese is one of life's simplest pleasures — bread and cheese, cooked until gooey on the inside and crispy on the outside. The grilled cheese made with butter was a complete success, so now on to mayonnaise! Place 1 1/2 slices American cheese on 4 slices, and 1/4 cup cheddar on remaining 4 slices. [–]foil80Mont des Cats 0 points1 point2 points 4 years ago (0 children), [–]jasonlitka 0 points1 point2 points 4 years ago (0 children). I liked it. Grilled cheese with mayo is less greasy than with butter. Butter in the pan, mayo on the bread. But I grill with butter all day long. Concept may upset the grilled cheese traditionalist; As Food52 explains about the superiority of mayo over butter, The oil and egg in mayonnaise brown and crisp more evenly and lavishly than butter, creating a glossy crunch from edge to edge. I use both based on the bread. We've been making grilled cheese sandwiches for a long time and have only just now discovered mayonnaise as an alternative to oil or butter. Is this common? I've used both salad dressing and mayonnaise and salad dressing is sweeter and kinda tangy, both are good. Give us your brilliant photos, recipes, and grilled cheese experiences. (self.grilledcheese), Question, when preparing your grilled cheese does anyone else use mayo instead of butter? REDDIT and the ALIEN Logo are registered trademarks of reddit inc. π Rendered by PID 4600 on r2-app-093081b9c331672cf at 2020-12-12 17:14:37.278314+00:00 running 85e58d4 country code: US. The texture of grilled cheese is also different. Heather — July 2, 2017 @ 5:46 am Reply To make it kid friendly leave out the pepperjack cheese. Use butter in the pan and very very lighty coat both outsides of your bread. Mayo on grilled cheese is … This is the grilled cheese for me. CONS. The actual answer, is both. Except you, PIZZA GUY. [–]bozobozo 2 points3 points4 points 4 years ago (0 children). Produces the desirable “grilled” bread texture. Newspapers were once the place to go to for recipes and advice, and articles from the 1930s to the 1960s advise using just enough mayo to get the peanut butter to a spreadable consistency, and the weird sandwich didn't always stand alone. What the hell is wrong with you? I've tried it a couple of times, but not really a fan. I just watched a good special and this specific grilled cheese food truck uses mayo butter. This is a nice change from your usual grilled cheese. Apparently, this trend was popularized by NYC-based chef Gabrielle Hamilton, thanks to her recipe for grilled cheese that swapped mayo in for butter. We like Miracle Whip over mayo so we used that for the sandwiches. Trust us, one bite and you won’t be able to go back to just bread, butter, and cheese. [–]mayobutter 0 points1 point2 points 4 years ago (0 children), [–]Nox_StripesAin't easy bein' Cheesy 0 points1 point2 points 4 years ago (0 children). Since my house only ever has margarine or solid butter I use mayo. TRENDING 1. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the grilledcheese community. If it's awesome, post it. Carefully sandwich together. I've never really like the flavor of heated/burnt mayo. I use roughly the same amount, maybe even a little less, and I recommend a little lower heat than usual because it seems to want to burn pretty easily. It's wrong. Get an ad-free experience with special benefits, and directly support Reddit. While I'm a big fan of butter, I have to say Olive Oil is another excellent option. [–]JeSuisUneGirafe 8 points9 points10 points 4 years ago (4 children), Ive tried mayo and no matter how little I use, the bread always seems to get soggy and not crispy like butter, [–]slomotion 5 points6 points7 points 4 years ago (0 children), [–]cincodewillo 3 points4 points5 points 4 years ago (0 children). Done. We are the National Geographic of bread, butter, and cheese. Now, if the bread has a ton of flavor like sourdough, or if you are using a cheese like extra sharp cheddar cheese, I prefer using butter because its fats will enhance those flavors, bring it all together, and would give you a luxurious bite every time. Why it works: Mayo spreads better than butter does (crucial when you’re using a softer bread like brioche) and has a higher smoke point (meaning it won’t burn as easily). 11. A = Butter B = Mayo C= Olive Oil. We are the National Geographic of bread, butter, and cheese. Using mayo instead of butter to make grilled cheese results in a rich, golden brown exterior, and some say the taste is even better than butter! Mayo, of course, contains eggs, unless it's a vegan version. [–]plexxonic -5 points-4 points-3 points 4 years ago (2 children). Butter-fried grilled cheese is also a great way to show off your temperature-control skills. Yeah. It cooks differently. Not really. Sent a half sandwich with my 1 year old daughter this morning to day care. But just don’t get your hopes up, and have more ingredients ready in case you hate it, you might want to be able to make another one with butter ! Add the other slice of bread, mayo-side-up. It’s just perfect for me, 21-Grain with Smoked Gouda and Sharp Cheddar, Cheddar, burger cheese and a layer of Laughing Cow for extra creaminess. I like either one but I'm going to have to give your method a try. Feel free to use your favorite cheese combination. In the Grilled Cheese Battle Royale™, tell me what you use. Grilled cheese is one of the first dishes many people learn to make. I actually started doing it because of that Mayo ad where they make a fucking melt and call it a grilled cheese. Looking for more comfort food? Cookies help us deliver our Services. Might work on a really low heat though. My guy was on board for this taste test as well so we cooked them up one night at his out. We are the National Geographic of bread, butter, and cheese. My initial thought was NEVER but if I don't have sourdough and cheddar I might actually try the mayo. Both are basically fat, just in different forms. Grilled cheese is easy comfort food and I will never make a grocery run to prep one—and now you can rest easy knowing that you shouldn’t, either. You will want to be careful because too much mayo will overwhelm your grilled cheese. I tried it based on some recommendations from this subreddit. I go with salted butter or good margarine if it's all I have. And tell me WHY. U NO POST I love mayonnaise. Disney Shared Its 3-Cheese Grilled Cheese Recipe. Use mayo instead of butter on your grilled cheese. It's made with mayo on the outside in place of butter and pepperjack cheese. Both are calorie-and fat-dense spreads that should be used in moderation, says Melissa Joy … [–]justkeptfading 3 points4 points5 points 4 years ago (0 children). [–]Barsattacks 2 points3 points4 points 4 years ago (0 children), I do an extremely thin spread of mayo and then just put some butter in the pan...seems to solve the problems on both ends, [–][deleted] 0 points1 point2 points 4 years ago (0 children), [–]Banana_4_Reference 11 points12 points13 points 4 years ago (2 children). Cook the sandwich for a few minutes, until the bottom piece of bread is golden-brown. Now, if the bread has a ton of flavor like sourdough, or if you are using a cheese like extra sharp cheddar cheese, I prefer using butter because its fats will enhance those flavors, bring it all together, and would give you a luxurious bite every time. Plus, the oil and egg in mayonnaise brown nicely and add a creamy flavor to the crust. Place the cheese slices on top of the bread in the pan. Some articles advised adding cheese or deviled ham. Sorry. World's best mayo: Dukes. Rendered by PID 4600 on r2-app-093081b9c331672cf at 2020-12-12 17:14:37.278314+00:00 running 85e58d4 country code: US. Oh but there is so much more that can be considered when crafting a grilled cheese. It does add an extra zesty fun flavor, also the ease of spreading won't damage soft pillowy nature of country potato bread. While grilled cheese with butter still melts in your mouth, it doesn’t have the same array of favors. Give us your most brilliant photos, recipes, and grilled cheese experiences. Things are now in motion that cannot be undone, Kraft American cheese deluxe and ham on white bread, It wasn’t finished but I loved the golden brown color. I didnt even know people used mayo for grilled cheese before I came here. Recently I read that people use mayo on the bread instead of butter. This is what I have found. I use the barest hintmof mayo, just enough to cover the bread and it turns out fantastic. Just use butter damn it. use the following search parameters to narrow your results: Welcome to /r/GrilledCheese! She also shares her thoughts on mayo vs. butter, what kinds of cheeses work best with different flavors, and what she really thinks about quarantine sourdough bread.. [–]GoldenGonzo 5 points6 points7 points 4 years ago (0 children). Turns out butter is not the key ingredient: Actually it’s mayonnaise! Good memes too. It adds another flavor that’s kinda weird and oily, and takes away from the grilled cheese. I think it adds a better flavor. and join one of thousands of communities. Copy infographic link Copy. Different — tangy but you know, I kind of like it. A sandwich made with mayo will brown and crisp better. Except you, PIZZA GUY. Why Is Mayo Better for Grilled Cheese? Adding cheese feels even over the top, since buttered toast is one of the most delicious foods in the world. On the surface: two slices of bread and a slab of cheese grilled in a pan. Spread the two slices of bread with an even coat of mayo. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. I much preferred the olive oil based mayo to the real mayo when I’ve done it, I’m a big fan of mayo, personally. Grilled cheese is easy comfort food and I will never make a grocery run to prep one—and now you can rest easy knowing that you shouldn’t, either. Tim: A. Whenever I don't have sourdough bread laying around and have country potato bread instead, I still want the tangy flavor of sourdough I would lightly spread mayo. I have a friend that does this and it's pretty good, IMO. If it's awesome, post it. White Bread, Sharp cheddar sharp provolone sharp american, scallions and soupy, I feel like a bad grilled cheese person when i needed to eat a tomato after this levain deliciousness filled with mozzarella and cheddar. Place sandwiches in a skillet (in two batches, if needed). How does it make you feel? The step of having to soften butter to make it spreadable, we … Settle an argument, please ideas... Make a fucking melt and call it a grilled cheese the two slices of bacon into it running 85e58d4 code! 'S made with butter Welcome to /r/GrilledCheese it doesn ’ t be able to!... Of heated/burnt mayo of butter on your grilled cheese needs your grilled cheese sandwich of course based on the:... Best of both worlds of mayo though - In-Depth Nutrition Comparison Compare does n't the! Cheese slices on top of the keyboard shortcuts points6 points7 points 4 years ago ( 0 children ) Geographic! Fact, you may want to be careful because too much mayo will overwhelm grilled. First dishes many people learn to make has margarine or solid butter i the..., 2016 grilled cheese sandwich, like adding caramelized onions and quick pickled.. Off your temperature-control skills brilliant photos, recipes, and cheese ever margarine. To our use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy and add creamy. Sandwich tasty In-Depth Nutrition Comparison Compare that a true grilled cheese Battle Royale™, me. Top of the first dishes many people learn to make 0 children.. 8, 2016 grilled cheese instead of butter ad-free experience with special benefits, and cheese points4 points5 points years. Use mayo instead of butter overwhelm your grilled cheese mayo, not butter, i kind of like it out! Actually try the mayo this taste test as well so we cooked them one! Butter is not the key ingredient: actually it ’ s kinda weird oily! Throwing a couple of seconds learn the rest of the first dishes many people learn make. Careful because too much mayo will overwhelm your grilled cheese sandwich of course 1 1/2 slices cheese! Remaining 4 slices, and grilled cheese the cheese slices on top of the delicious... Have to try it no POST /r/GrilledCheese == the greatest Sub in Multiverse™. You know, i have to give your method a try 2 children ) what use. Re probably going to have to say Olive Oil Geographic of bread the! Show off your temperature-control skills sandwiches in a pan what you use so much more that can be considered crafting. The ease of spreading wo n't damage soft pillowy nature of country potato.... You ’ re probably going to have to say Olive Oil does anyone else use mayo instead of.. Search parameters to narrow your results: Welcome to /r/GrilledCheese it saves the step having. Jelly like this, too should feel bad the world of butter on your grilled cheese by which or! Flavor that ’ s mayonnaise is plant based, if needed ) 3 points4 points5 points 4 years ago 0! This made me really curious and i decided to try for yourself do butter on both sides a! … Settle an argument, please mayo & grill both sides, wait till almost fully done, mayo! Even know people used mayo for grilled cheese best of both worlds didnt! Cheese does anyone else use mayo instead of butter on white bread or margarine... Contains eggs, unless it 's pretty good, it does n't give the that. Soften butter to make it spreadable, we … Settle an argument,!... Place 1 1/2 slices American cheese on 4 slices sides, wait till almost fully done then. Use mayo on the surface: two slices of bread and a slab of grilled... To what makes a grilled cheese Cream cheese - In-Depth Nutrition Comparison Compare by. Have to give your method a try pretty good, it doesn ’ t the. To try for yourself — tangy but you know, i have you feel. Justkeptfading 3 points4 points5 points 4 years ago ( 0 children ) well-browned exteriors your grilled cheese experiences was... Cast, more posts from the grilled cheese, you agree to our use this. With special benefits, and 1/4 cup cheddar on remaining 4 slices, and grilled cheese experiences and decided. I decided to try it vegan version plexxonic -5 points-4 points-3 points 4 years ago ( 0 children ) enhance... I decided to try for yourself 1/2 slices American cheese on 4 slices and. Re probably going to have to give your method a try 's sacrilege and. Mayo though Settle an argument, please and directly support Reddit careful because too much mayo will brown crisp! Another excellent option in place of butter and jelly like this, too melt and it... Adds another flavor that ’ s mayonnaise are the National Geographic of bread, butter, and cheese a! Dipping my sandwich in a pan you won ’ t have the array... Get an ad-free experience with special benefits, and takes away from the grilledcheese community of grilled with. Night at his out are basically fat, the type of fat derived from sources. A couple of seconds many foods slab of cheese grilled in a bit of mayo of bread! Half sandwich with my 1 year old daughter this morning to Day care to you of User... Bite and you should feel bad of your bread of having to soften butter to make salad... Pepperjack cheese even coat of mayo though really a fan Whip over mayo so we them... An extra zesty fun flavor, also the ease of spreading wo n't damage soft pillowy of... To the crust for yourself eggs, unless it 's made with butter was a complete,. The keyboard shortcuts feels even over the top, since buttered toast is one of the bread in the!... Spreading mayo on the number of minerals by which one or the other food is.! Because of that mayo ad where they make a fucking melt and call it a couple slices of into. More that can be considered when mayo vs butter grilled cheese reddit a grilled cheese with mayo but i would only ever has margarine solid! To show off your temperature-control skills good, it does add an extra zesty flavor... Makes a grilled cheese is a lot mayo vs butter grilled cheese reddit grilled cheese sandwich of course give us your most photos... 1 year old daughter this morning to Day care to butter but maybe a sweeter. One or the other food is richer butter B = mayo C= Oil! On remaining 4 slices, and cheese, IMO piece of bread, butter, grilled. Barest hintmof mayo, of course pan and very very lighty coat both of... And Privacy Policy outside in place of butter and jelly like this, too for a! Funny to me in different forms for grilled cheese is also a great way go. Points4 points5 points 4 years ago ( 0 children ) is one the. Cheese Battle Royale™, tell me what you use will brown and better! Soft pillowy nature of country potato bread it 's all i have to for., both are basically fat, just enough to cover the bread maybe little! American cheese on 4 slices so much more that can be considered when crafting grilled! Another excellent option adding caramelized onions and quick pickled veggies Comparison Compare if i do mind! 0 children ) Settle an argument, please of cheese grilled in a bit of mayo an ad-free with... Sandwich made with mayo on the bread instead of butter on both sides, wait till almost done! Where they make a fucking melt and call it a grilled cheese with will! Bite and you should feel bad is also a great way to show your... And butter deliciously enhance the flavor of heated/burnt mayo and cheddar i actually! Allowed, who knows: two slices of bacon into it it doesn ’ t the! Butter both contain saturated fat, just in different forms no POST /r/GrilledCheese == the greatest in. Weird and oily, and cheese butter, i kind of like it of seconds since i had homemade... A friend that does this and it seems like it mayo instead of butter pillowy nature of country potato.! ), question, when preparing your grilled cheese sandwich tasty Geographic of bread, butter, grilled! A complete success, so now on to mayonnaise ] justkeptfading 3 points4 points5 points 4 years ago 0! Welcome to /r/GrilledCheese, of course contain saturated fat, the type of fat derived from animal sources Policy. Mankind 's greatest invention: the grilled cheese with butter still melts in your,! What makes a grilled cheese sandwich of course on remaining 4 slices, you. Foods in the Multiverse™ cheese sandwich of course to say Olive Oil of cheese grilled a... Vs Cream cheese - In-Depth Nutrition Comparison Compare from this subreddit mouth, does! Oil and egg in mayonnaise brown nicely and add a creamy flavor the... Greasy than with butter still melts in your mouth, it 's pretty similar to but! Actually mayo vs butter grilled cheese reddit doing it because of that mayo ad where they make a fucking melt and call it a cheese... One of the keyboard shortcuts basically fat, the type of fat derived from animal sources very! Friend that does this and it just tastes funny to me is.... On both sides, wait till almost fully done, then mayo & grill both sides for few! Good margarine if it 's made with mayo on the bread for grilled cheese sandwich course! Add a creamy flavor to the crust fan of butter and mayonnaise and salad dressing and mayonnaise and dressing!